New York sales tax audits rarely start with a phone call. New York taxpayers often wonder – why has my business been selected for a New York sales tax audit? To the surprise of many New York businesses, New York sales tax audits begin quietly when the New York Department of Tax and Finance receives an inside data feed.
Over the past years, New York businesses across nearly every industry have been surprised by New York sales tax desk audit letters questioning reported gross sales, even when sales-tax returns were filed on time, and tax was fully paid. In many of these cases, the audit was not triggered by a customer complaint, whistleblower, or field visit, but by a perceived mismatch between federal Form 1099-K data and New York sales tax filings.
In recent years, this issue has quickly become one of the most consistent and frequent audit triggers used by the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance. E‑commerce sellers, service providers using third‑party credit card processors, restaurants, professional services firms, and hybrid businesses that sell through multiple channels are especially vulnerable to mismatches between 1099-K data and New York sales tax filings. Understanding why these mismatches occur, and how to address them before the sales tax audit escalates, can be the primary difference between a short desk review and a multi‑year field audit with hefty penalties and interest.
WHY NEW YORK SALES TAX AUDITORS RELY ON 1099-K DATA
New York has long relied on third‑party data to identify audit candidates and New York sales tax filing inconsistencies, but Form 1099-K has become one of the most efficient tools in the New York sales tax audit selection process.
With the expansion of 1099‑K reporting requirements, more businesses than ever are now visible to tax authorities. Payment processors such as Stripe, PayPal, Square, Amazon, Etsy, Shopify, and Uber Eats report gross transaction volumes and sales that are easily compared to reported sales on sales tax returns.
From the Department’s perspective, this data is appealing because it appears to be both objective and comprehensive. A 1099‑K shows total payments processed for a merchant during the year, regardless of whether those payments represent taxable sales, nontaxable services, reimbursements, refunds, credits, discounts, tips, or marketplace transactions. At a basic level, when the total dollar figure on a 1099-K exceeds the gross receipts reported on New York sales‑tax returns, auditors often assume that New York taxable sales were omitted.
The flaw in this approach is that a 1099‑K is not a sales tax document. At its core, New York sales tax is due on taxable sales sourced into New York. 1099-K data does not distinguish between taxable and nontaxable receipts, does not distinguish between New York sourced sales and out-of-state source sales, does not remove refunds and related non-taxable items, does not consider sales tax collected and remitted, does not contemplate exempt sales, like sale for resale, and frequently includes sales where tax collection responsibility lies with a marketplace facilitator rather than the seller. Despite these limitations, mismatches routinely trigger audit notices.
HOW 1099-K MISMATCHES TURN INTO SALES TAX FIELD AUDITS
Before responding to a New York sales tax audit notice, make sure your numbers are reconciled correctly.
Creating a free Sales Tax Helper account allows you to review your 1099-K data, organize supporting records, and schedule a confidential consultation to determine the best audit response strategy
Most 1099‑K cases begin as a simple desk audit. The New York Department of Tax and Finance issues a letter requesting an explanation for the discrepancy between reported sales and third‑party payment data. The response window is often short, typically thirty days, and extensions are not guaranteed.
If the response is incomplete, unclear, or unsupported by proper sales tax documentation, the case frequently escalates into a field audit. At that point, the scope expands beyond the original mismatch and frequently turns into a detailed sales and use tax audit of sales, expenses and fixed assets. New York sales tax auditors will expand the audit to three years for filers, and if no returns were filed, the expansion will be from the inception of the company’s operation. The sales tax document requests are often extensive, involving multiple years of records, an application of statistical sampling, and a calculated estimated assessment based on perceived and unwarranted error rates.
Common causes of escalation include confusion between point‑of‑sale data and bank deposits, misunderstanding of marketplace facilitator rules, failure to segregate in-state sales from out-of-state sales, and failure to reconcile timing differences between transaction dates and settlement dates. What begins as a reconciliation issue can quickly turn into an assessment for underreporting.
FIVE COMMON SOLUTIONS BEFORE THE SALES TAX AUDITOR ARRIVES
Need help reconciling your 1099-K data before the audit expands?
Create a free Sales Tax Helper account to access guided reconciliation tools and schedule a consultation with a New York sales tax audit professional.
Most 1099‑K mismatches can be resolved if addressed early and systematically.
First, reconcile daily point‑of‑sale Z‑tapes and X-Tapes or transaction summaries to actual deposits. Differences often arise from processor fees, chargebacks, refunds, tax collected and remitted, or batch timing errors. A clear and concise reconciliation demonstrating that taxable sales were properly recorded is often sufficient to resolve the issue during the desk audit.
Second, identify marketplace facilitator and related exempt transactions. Many businesses mistakenly report marketplace and exempt sales as taxable transactions on their returns even though the platform collected and remitted the tax or the transaction, as a whole, is exempt from sales tax. Removing these transactions frequently explains a substantial portion of the mismatch.
Third, Form 1099-K reports gross payment volume, not taxable, New York sourced, receipts. Amounts such as sales tax collected and remitted, reimbursements, tips, deposits, intercompany transfers, loans, owner contributions, gift card sales, and returns processed outside the original period are frequently embedded in 1099-K data. Preparing a schedule that cleanly backs out non-taxable and non-sales receipts, tied and supported to bank statements and POS reports, often resolves discrepancies without expanding the audit.
Fourth, document timing and accrual differences between returns, processors, and financial records. Sales tax returns are typically filed on an accrual basis, while 1099-K data reflect settlement date of cash-based activity. End-of-month batch delays, holiday processing lags, and year-end cutoffs commonly cause mismatches across periods. A short timing reconciliation showing when transactions were booked versus when they settled can neutralize perceived underreporting and prevent auditors from asserting error-rate extrapolations.
Fifth, and most importantly, control the narrative. Here, this is where Sales Tax Helper comes into play. It Is crucial to control the audit narrative by establishing the taxpayer’s accounting method and data early. Auditors often default to 1099-K data as the “best available information.” By formally establishing the taxpayer’s books and records, point-of-sale system, and return methodology as the primary source of truth, before document requests escalate, the taxpayer can limit the auditor’s ability to substitute third-party processor data or impose estimated methodologies.
CASE SNAPSHOT: SALES TAX HELPER ADVISES SHOPIFY SELLER REDUCE LIABILITY
Every audit turns on the quality of the reconciliation and the narrative presented.
Create a free Sales Tax Helper account to evaluate your own 1099-K exposure and schedule a consultation before the audit scope expands.
Our client, a New York‑based online retailer selling handmade goods, received a desk audit letter alleging significant underreported sales based on 1099‑K data. The New York Audit Division proposed a substantial assessment covering multiple quarters.
A detailed reconciliation carried out by our trained and experienced internal auditors showed that more than half of the reported 1099‑K receipts consisted of out-of-state and exempt sales, for which our client did not have the responsibility for collecting and remitting sales tax. Additional differences were traced to refunds and processing fees. After creating a clear and concise gameplan, controlling the narrative, and submitting detailed documentation, the proposed liability was reduced by approximately sixty percent, and the audit closed without substantial penalties.
1099-K MISMATCH‑REPAIR CHECKLIST FOR YOUR SALES TAX AUDIT
Want help working through this checklist the right way?
By creating a free Sales Tax Helper account, you can organize your documents, track reconciliation issues, and schedule a consultation to review your audit readiness before responding to the Department.
Before responding to any New York sales‑tax audit involving a 1099‑K mismatch, businesses should gather bank statements, merchant processor reports, point‑of‑sale summaries, marketplace transaction detail, and copies of filed and amended ST‑100 returns. Having these records organized and reconciled can significantly reduce audit duration and exposure. The Sales Tax Helper platform can assist with creating a clear checklist for addressing the 1099-K mismatch.
CONCLUSION
1099‑K mismatches are no longer rare anomalies, they are routine audit triggers for New York sales tax audits. Businesses that ignore these sales tax notices risk broader audits, estimated assessments, and hefty penalties. Those that address mismatches early, with clear reconciliations and documentation, often resolve matters quickly and favorably.
Received a New York sales tax audit letter and you are concerned a 1099-K mismatch exists?
Do not respond until the numbers are reconciled.
Create a free Sales Tax Helper account to review your situation, organize your records, and schedule a confidential consultation to determine your next steps.