Texas Voluntary Disclosure Agreements for Online Retailers and SaaS Companies: The Rule With No Lookback Cap
We regularly get calls from online retailers that sell using Shopify. Many incorrectly believe, however, that Shopify is not only charging the correct amount of sales tax to the customers in states it is turned on for, but also handling the sales tax compliance. To their surprise, the sales tax proceeds were collected and then deposited with the business, not turned over to the state. This is about the point at which panic sets in as the business realizes they are not only behind in their compliance but also have a massive sales tax collected but not remitted problem, which carries penalties, personal liability and could even result in criminal issues.
A Texas-based online retailer recently called with a similar issue. In short, they found out that Shopify had collected sales tax at the point of sale for two years, but deposited it with the business, not with the state. While she was relieved the taxes were collected, panic set in as it was uncovered that the money was not being reported and sales tax compliance was not handled. Of course, the problem did not stop with just Texas. It was a systemic issue in many states.
I've represented companies in sales tax audits and voluntary disclosures for more than 15 years. During this time I became familiar with the growing pains of companies and started Sales Tax Helper to assist in these areas. I've handled more than 5,000 cases in more than 40 states and, in my experience, the Shopify/Stripe collection-versus-remittance gap is one of the more costly mistakes in an online retail and SaaS business. Texas is one of the more aggressive states in the U.S. in pursuing these types of errors.
Once revenues reach $500,000 over any 12 month period from Texas sales, exposure begins. Each month Shopify or Stripe fails to collect and remit the tax adds to a state and local liability of 6.25 percent plus up to 2 percent, and a four year statute of limitations doesn't apply to the tax that was collected and never remitted. And remember, just because tax is turned "on" in Shopify does not mean the problem is gone.
Texas — Sales Tax
Why "Shopify Is Handling It" Is the Costliest Assumption an Online Retailer or SaaS Company Can Make
VDA Process
Identify Exposure
Find states where you have nexus but haven't registered
Calculate Liability
Estimate tax owed over the lookback period
Approach Anonymously
Contact the state through a representative — no identity required yet
Negotiate Terms
Agree on lookback period, penalty waivers, and conditions
Execute Agreement
Sign the VDA and lock in the agreed terms
File & Pay
Submit returns and remit payment for all covered periods
What Shopify Tax and Stripe Tax Actually Do
Shopify Tax and Stripe Tax calculate the correct rate at checkout and collect it from the customer. Neither files a return or remits the money, unless you have specifically enrolled in an added filing service. Most merchants skip that step, and it is even spelled out in Shopify's literature. Shopify says this directly: it does not remit sales tax, unless your U.S. sales tax is specifically managed by Shopify, or your store is enrolled in automated filing.
Stripe has similar literature, and Stripe says the same thing.
If you are utilizing either platform for service, the result is the same. The sales tax remittance and compliance falls on the business. Contrary to popular belief, Shopify is not a marketplace facilitator for your store like Amazon or Etsy is; those platforms collect and remit sales tax for sellers, while Shopify and Stripe do not.
How the Collection-Remittance Gap Becomes a Multi-State Liability Without Anyone Deciding It Should
It sneaks up on businesses. Retailers enter a new state's economic nexus and suddenly orders become taxable. For many, that can happen during the busy holiday season. Shopify can recognize nexus, flag it, and allow you to easily start charging sales tax for its customers in these situations. The clients of Shopify, like other online retailers, have lots of orders and not a lot of time to think about filing new business registrations. So tax collection software continues to be used in more and more states without anyone ever officially registering the business.
SaaS companies face the same issue from another perspective. A founder sets up Stripe to charge subscriptions, and then Stripe taxes and collects based on the customer's location. With tax questions resolved, as money is visibly withheld at checkout, the issue is considered solved. However, money is withheld but not filed, and a business must be registered in each of those states for the taxes to be remitted. As a result, a SaaS company can also amass unremitted taxes just like a retailer, and often faster, given subscription billing occurs monthly, without verifying where customers are located.
Each month the software runs without being caught, the more damage it causes to the business. It may take several months before the business owner catches on to the problem. By then, the owner would have suffered immense losses.
Why Texas Is a Uniquely Dangerous State to Get This Wrong Right Now
The Texas Rule That Makes Collected-and-Unremitted Tax Especially Dangerous
In states like Texas, a voluntary disclosure can be a solution to this common issue. Texas Comptroller Publication 96-576 states that a standard voluntary disclosure agreement (VDA) caps review at four years from the time of the disclosure, and statutory penalties and interest are waived, except for interest on taxes collected and not remitted. However, if you are caught by the Comptroller, expect large penalties, personal liability, and even criminal implications to go along with extended lookback periods.
How a Texas Voluntary Disclosure Agreement Actually Works
Eligibility and the Window That Closes the Moment Texas Contacts You First
Like most states, a Texas VDA is only available if the Comptroller has not already made contact with you regarding the tax in question, according to Texas Comptroller Publication 96-576. Making contact means sending you a letter or calling you. It can also mean a notice triggered by a 1099-K or other system mismatch. The state's systems have been known to flag mismatches and other issues. Once contact is made, the window to apply for voluntary disclosure closes. To be clear, we laid out the complete process in our guide on the Texas voluntary disclosure program, and what determines eligibility is equally simple, applying before the state comes knocking.
What You Get in Return: Penalty Waivers and a Capped Lookback, Except on Collected-Not-Remitted Tax
A Texas VDA limits a review to the past four years for tax not reported at all. Compared to an audit, this is a significant reduction. Penalties for statutory violations are waived entirely for a properly filed VDA, and so is interest, with one exception. Interest continues to accrue on the tax that was collected but not remitted. The cap on the lookback period does not apply to that tax, which is why mapping the dollars before filing a VDA determines how much you stand to save.
Building a Defensible Texas VDA Strategy for Online Retail and SaaS
Mapping Real Exposure Across Every Platform Before Contacting the Comptroller
Before reaching out to the Comptroller's office, retrieve the actual transaction data from every platform where your business transacts in Texas. This includes your Shopify and Stripe data, as well as Amazon FBA records and any other place where your business collects revenues. Separate what was collected but never remitted from what was never collected. In Publication 96-576, these are treated differently.
Crossing that threshold 18 to 24 months ago and correcting for it now means minor adjustments are out of the question. Expect a cost range from the mid-five to low-six figures, and that's before the Comptroller steps in and imposes penalties. Because there is no limit on how far back the Comptroller can look at collected tax and how much the state can charge, the final cost can be much higher.
What a Properly Run VDA Can Save You in Penalties and Interest
Voluntary disclosure provides an opportunity to come into compliance with the state of Texas and significantly reduce the potential penalties and interest that may be assessed during a subsequent audit. Texas currently does not have a sales tax amnesty program. The urgency is that the Texas Comptroller's office will continue to cross-check taxpayer data against registration records in order to determine potential noncompliance. Additionally, the Comptroller's office may initiate an audit at any time.
The business in the scenario didn't have a hard deadline, but chose to come forward of her own accord. She had two years of data showing the revenue gap on Shopify, and under Texas law, taking more time to disclose meant exposure with no limit kept growing. We have a team of lawyers, CPAs, and former state audit staff who analyze potential exposure and provide recommendations before our first call to the Comptroller. Learn more about our services regarding Texas Voluntary Disclosure Agreements.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Shopify or Stripe file my Texas sales tax returns for me?
Neither service automatically registers your business, files returns or pays taxes for you. You must sign up for an additional service and enroll in automated filing for either to take that action. Most merchants have not signed up for either additional service.
What happens if I collected Texas sales tax but never remitted it?
Per Texas Comptroller Publication 96-576, voluntary disclosure agreements do not limit the review of tax that was collected and not remitted to a lookback period. The usual four-year lookback period will not limit the exposure for taxes that were not remitted to the state.
Is there a Texas sales tax amnesty program in 2026?
No. The active 2026 Comptroller amnesty program only covers unauthorized, non-admitted insurance premiums and does not cover sales tax. The State of Texas is not currently offering a sales tax amnesty program.
How far back can the Texas Comptroller go if I never registered for a sales tax permit?
Generally, if you failed to collect the tax, a review is limited to the last four years. If a voluntary disclosure includes situations where the tax was collected from customers and was not remitted to the State, the Comptroller has no limit on how far back it can look.
Does my SaaS company owe Texas sales tax if we don't have an office there?
Yes. You reach economic nexus in Texas once your total revenue from the previous 12 months passes $500,000. Texas does not exempt SaaS from sales tax. Instead, it is considered a data processing service and taxed on 80% of the total charge.
What is the Texas economic nexus threshold for out-of-state sellers?
There is no separate transaction requirement. Nexus is created once business revenue from all related transactions exceeds $500,000 within a 12-month period. The business is not required to have notice of reaching this revenue threshold to create nexus.
Can I file a Texas VDA anonymously before identifying my business?
Yes, the Texas voluntary disclosure process includes an opportunity for an initial submission that can be made under anonymity or limited identity. During this first submission, you can work out terms with the State before finalizing your disclosure. More information on voluntary disclosure in Texas is available in our comprehensive report on the Texas voluntary disclosure program.
What happens if the Texas Comptroller contacts me before I file a VDA?
If the Comptroller's office contacts you about a tax in question, whether through a letter or phone call, or if a tax notice is generated from a data mismatch, the option to make a voluntary disclosure is no longer available and an audit will be initiated.
Will a Texas VDA waive penalties and interest on unpaid sales tax?
A VDA submitted and processed in the correct way eliminates statutory penalties and interest on tax that was not collected. Interest on tax that was collected and not remitted remains owed and is outside the four-year lookback period.
How is SaaS taxed differently than physical products in Texas?
Per the Texas Comptroller, Software-as-a-Service (SaaS) is a data processing service, and 80 percent of the charge is taxable, and 20 percent is exempt, under Tax Code Section 151.351. The Texas Comptroller updated its data processing services rule effective April 2, 2025. Most other taxable services are taxed on the full sales price, and exemptions apply to specific services.
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, or accounting advice. Sales tax rates, sourcing rules, and statutory definitions change frequently and vary by jurisdiction and by the specific facts of your situation. You should not rely on this article as a substitute for advice from a qualified professional. No attorney-client relationship is created by reading this article.
About the Author
Gerald J. "Jerry" Donnini II is a sales tax attorney and the founder of Sales Tax Helper, a national platform that helps businesses find, fix, and prevent sales tax exposure before it becomes a problem. Over a 15-year career, he has represented businesses in more than 5,000 sales tax audits, appeals, and disputes across 40+ states. He holds an LLM in Taxation from New York University, is co-author of a CCH treatise on state sales and use tax, and serves as an adjunct law professor. Jerry has saved businesses more than $500 million in sales tax assessments. His framework, Find It. Fix It. Defend It., guides businesses from initial nexus diagnosis through voluntary disclosure and, when necessary, full audit defense.
Need Expert Help?
Our team of attorneys, CPAs, and former state auditors handles exactly these situations. Free consultation — no obligation.
Get Started FreeTalk to an ExpertHave a sales tax problem?
Our team handles hundreds of audits, appeals, and compliance cases each year.
Get a Free Consultation